Angels Technology

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Thursday, September 20, 2012

Vmware esxi host clusters : one large or several/multiple smaller clusters

Posted on 10:28 AM by Unknown

A recent discussion came up where a forum member has a setup of older hosts in one cluster and a set of newer hosts in another cluster

The question was should they combine the cluster or should they leave it as a set of smaller clusters.


Questions to ask:

How many hosts are we dealing with?
The maximum in a cluster is 32 hosts (see here )
If the number is above or close to 32, maybe you are better of distributing them.
If we are dealing with 4-5 hosts, its better to keep them together

How different are the hosts' hardware?
Are there significant cpu enhancements on the newer hosts that your vms will take advantage of?
Then  use different clusters
Are the hosts different cpu types? Intel and AMD?
Then of course, use different clusters
Are the cpu enhancements not important?
Then you might want to keep them together

How is HA configured?
Is admission control policy based upon host failures or percentage of cluster resources?
A larger cluster can tolerate hosts failures better

Wha are the distances between the hosts?
If the hosts are in the same datacenter  one cluster is better.
Are they spread out over different buildings or distance. Depends on latency and requirements.
If one set of hosts is in NY and the other is in Virginia then it makes sense to use different clusters.
If the hosts are in a wan with low latency, it depends on bandwith ,etc

Is DRS enabled?
A larger cluster can distribute load across more hosts.
When entering maintenance mode,  more hosts  mean more resources for downtime.


The answer really depends on your needs and limitations that you have to work with.

I prefer larger clusters for their ability to handle faults better due to larger numbers
Duncan Epping is also on that track
"Typically, I feel that most environments would benefit from 1 large cluster... if you compare it to the benefit they would have from not using EVC I think it is neglectable. go big!"
Pasted from <http://communities.vmware.com/message/2117798#2117798>

here is a article by Duncan on the topic : http://www.yellow-bricks.com/2012/04/10/cluster-sizes-vsphere-5-style/
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in cluster, vcenter, vm, vmware, vsphere | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Convert your physical RDM (rdmp) to a virtual RDM (rdmv)
    So you have a raw disk mapping on your virtual machine in esxi   and you wanted to convert it from a rdmp to a rdmv. Using the VMware cli...
  • VM script : To Get the VM data with Snapshot, Datastore, Total Disk Size, Cluster Name, OS Name
    Here is a good script I came across which get's some details of a virtual machine: Its from the technet script repository : here # To Ge...
  • How to run a powershell script for vmware : walkthrough
    Here is a walk through on how to make and run a powershell /powercli script The methods also apply to powershell but this is target towa...
  • convert thick disk to thin using a command line via the vmkfstools on the esxi host
    So you have a thick provisioned disk and you want to convert it to a thin provisioned disk. Another issue you have is that you don’t have ...
  • Visualesxtop problems starting the java bat file
    What is it: Visualesxtop, a new fling that gives you a graphical way to view esxtop data Get it here http://labs.vmware.com/flings/visua...
  • Setting your esxi host to restart automatically after crash or purple screen aka psod
    The default and recommended setting is to leave the purple screen of death up to help you notice that het host has died and also leave t...
  • Browsing Vmware logs in the DCUI (view esxi logs via console)
    Why would you view your logs in the console? Well sometimes it's the only place that is accessible if there is an error. Go to your DC...
  • Vmware DRS anti affinity rules wont let you enter maintenance mode for a esxi host
    You have a DRS rule that specifies that 2 vms need to be kept apart: In this case: 250-FT and 250sql3 For larger clusters with multiple...
  • How to read PSOD errors on your esxi host
    Here are some links that are useful to help you interpret why psod errors are happening. Machine Check Exception errors: mce http://kb.vmwar...
  • Migrating VMs : don’t use OVA/OVF?
    Don’t use OVF to move virtual machines around in your environment? Interesting thread here, http://communities.vmware.com/message/2110421 ...

Categories

  • 5.1
  • backup
  • cloud
  • cluster
  • command line
  • console
  • converter
  • cpu
  • datacenter
  • datastore
  • datastore. rdm
  • DCUI
  • dell
  • disaster recovery
  • display
  • DR
  • e1000
  • e1000e
  • ec2
  • esx
  • esxi
  • esxtop
  • extent
  • Good for enterprise
  • HA
  • hcl
  • host
  • HP
  • ibm
  • iometer
  • iscsi
  • iso
  • linked mode
  • logs
  • MAC
  • memory
  • NFS
  • NIC
  • NTP
  • ova
  • ovf
  • p2v
  • pcie
  • performance
  • phone
  • powercli
  • powershell
  • PSOD
  • raid
  • RDM
  • resource pool
  • rvtools
  • scsi
  • sddc
  • snapshots
  • SQL
  • SRM
  • ssh
  • storage
  • svmotion
  • syslog collector
  • v2v
  • vapp
  • vcenter
  • vcloud
  • vcp
  • veeam
  • VI console
  • vm
  • vmdk
  • VMFS
  • vmkfstools
  • vmotion
  • VMUG
  • vmware
  • vmware tools
  • vmware.esxi
  • vmxnet3
  • vsphere
  • vum
  • web client
  • windows

Blog Archive

  • ►  2013 (28)
    • ►  October (2)
    • ►  September (1)
    • ►  August (1)
    • ►  July (1)
    • ►  June (14)
    • ►  May (1)
    • ►  April (1)
    • ►  March (5)
    • ►  February (1)
    • ►  January (1)
  • ▼  2012 (138)
    • ►  December (2)
    • ►  November (13)
    • ►  October (26)
    • ▼  September (19)
      • Clone a vm using powercli
      • Svmotion RDM to vmdk virtual disk
      • Convert your physical RDM (rdmp) to a virtual RDM ...
      • VMDK per VMFS : Why use a one to one (1:1) ratio?
      • error VMware converter 5.0 will crash when using v...
      • Mac OSX 10.8 Support for ESXi 5.1
      • Can you rename a vmdk of a running vm in datastore...
      • How to import and deploy a ova or ovf file in the ...
      • Vmware esxi host clusters : one large or several/m...
      • Can you shrink a vmdk? Make a vmware hard disk sma...
      • IBM's customized vmware esxi iso
      • Can't increase the disk size of a vm
      • Cannot make a new resource pool or new vApp : gray...
      • Modifying VMware Syslog Collector settings : incre...
      • Migrating VMs : don’t use OVA/OVF?
      • HP blades: hardware hba iscsi causes PSOD (purple ...
      • Multiple datastores (VMFS) on a lun : vmware : not...
      • Unable to connect to the MKS: Failed to connect to...
      • vmware esxi and IBM x3850 M2 ESXi 5 host stops res...
    • ►  August (35)
    • ►  July (34)
    • ►  June (9)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile